[x3d-public] Prelude plus a bit of X3DTidy and X3dToJson stylesheet complaints

[John Carlson]

Okay, I am seeing omitObsoleteAttributes in X3dTidy.xslt documentation, and
stripDefaultAttributes in X3dToJson.xslt documentation, something to try
out.  I was hoping for a “do not add additional default values” in
X3dToJson.xslt.  Use the author’s intention.

Is there something to add containerFields where required by X3DJSAIL?  I’m
working on that in X3DJSONLD.java.

No need to rush to fix these things.  I don’t have a pressing need.

Hmm!

John

On Thu, Oct 26, 2023 at 9:21 AM John Carlson <yottzumm at gmail.com> wrote:

> So I've been working on X3DJSONLD.java JSON to XML conversion.  Since
> there are many additions through the use of X3dToJson.xslt, namely @ulimit
> and and @llimit properties which have default values, I cannot properly
> diff my XML HAnim output against the original XML X3D. I can delete these
> defaults X3DJSONLD.java and X3DJSONLD.js, but that seems like it's
> adding some complexity, which perhaps is unnecessary.
>
> So I thought, maybe I can use the X3d Tidy spreadsheet to remove these
> defaults.  Maybe not..
>
> Here is the X3d Tidy spreadsheet running against the original
> KoreanCharacterMotionAnnexD01Jin.x3d, which I believe is here:
>
>
> https://www.web3d.org/x3d-resources/content/examples/HumanoidAnimation/Specifications/KoreanCharacterMotionAnnexD01JinIndex.html
>
> I discovered all these ulimit and llimit fields being added to my tidied
> output! See attached original and tidied XML output. See below for false
> flags announcing that ulimit and llimit are omitted, when they are not.
>
> See:
>
>
> https://www.web3d.org/specifications/X3Dv4Draft/ISO-IEC19775-1v4-DIS/Part01/components/hanim.html#HAnimJoint
>
> For ulimit and llimit defaults.
>
> I am using Saxon as packaged with X3DJSAIL.  I am not testing with the
> latest X3DJSAIL jar, but I'll download that now.
>
> Thanks!
>
> John
>
> batchtidy:
>      [echo] Run tidy:
>     [apply] outdir
>     [apply] BEGIN
> C:\Users\john\x3dschema\examples\KoreanCharacterMotionAnnexD01Jin.x3d
>     [apply] out
> C:\Users\john\x3dschema\examples\KoreanCharacterMotionAnnexD01Jin.tidy.new.xml
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_humanoid_root'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_humanoid_root'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_sacroiliac' containerField='joints'
> has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_sacroiliac' containerField='joints'
> has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_vl5' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_vl5' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_skullbase' containerField='joints'
> has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_skullbase' containerField='joints'
> has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_elbow' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_elbow' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_elbow' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_elbow' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_hip' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_hip' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_hip' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_hip' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_knee' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_knee' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_knee' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_knee' containerField='joints' has
> disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_metatarsophalangeal_2'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_metatarsophalangeal_2'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_metatarsophalangeal_2'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_metatarsophalangeal_2'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_radiocarpal'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_radiocarpal'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_radiocarpal'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_radiocarpal'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_shoulder' containerField='joints'
> has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_shoulder' containerField='joints'
> has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_shoulder' containerField='joints'
> has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_shoulder' containerField='joints'
> has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_talocrural'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_l_talocrural'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_talocrural'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute llimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** HAnimJoint USE='hanim_r_talocrural'
> containerField='joints' has disallowed attribute ulimit='0 0 0', now omitted
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply]
> C:\Users\john\x3dschema\examples\KoreanCharacterMotionAnnexD01Jin.tidy.new.xml
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply] *** containerField mismatch - found it #3 containerField
> DEF='' containerField='segments' expectedContainerField='segments'
>     [apply]
> =======================================================================================================
>     [apply] HAnimHumanoid skeleton holds X3D4 HAnim2 triplets, HAnimJoint
> (18) : HAnimSegment (18) : HAnimSite (0)
>     [apply]
> =======================================================================================================
>     [apply] HAnimHumanoid DEF='hanim_AnnexD01Jin name='AnnexD01Jin'
> loa='-1'
>     [apply]   humanoid_root : sacrum
>     [apply]     sacroiliac : pelvis
>     [apply]       l_hip : l_thigh
>     [apply]       | l_knee : l_calf
>     [apply]       |   l_talocrural : l_talus
>     [apply]       |     l_metatarsophalangeal_2 :
> l_tarsal_proximal_phalanx_2
>     [apply]       r_hip : r_thigh
>     [apply]       | r_knee : r_calf
>     [apply]       |   r_talocrural : r_talus
>     [apply]       |     r_metatarsophalangeal_2 :
> r_tarsal_proximal_phalanx_2
>     [apply]       vl5 : l5
>     [apply]         skullbase : skull
>     [apply]         l_shoulder : l_upperarm
>     [apply]         | l_elbow : l_forearm
>     [apply]         |   l_radiocarpal : l_carpal
>     [apply]         r_shoulder : r_upperarm
>     [apply]           r_elbow : r_forearm
>     [apply]             r_radiocarpal : r_carpal
>     [apply]
> =======================================================================================================
>     [apply] END
> C:\Users\john\x3dschema\examples\KoreanCharacterMotionAnnexD01Jin.x3d
>
> BUILD SUCCESSFUL
> Total time: 3 seconds
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://web3d.org/pipermail/x3d-public_web3d.org/attachments/20231026/346f5acd/attachment-0001.html>