[x3d-public] reading schematron diagnostics

[John Carlson]

Don, I don't see any updates to X3D validator, so errors will still 
appear as hints.  Likely, you are busy.  Schematron is still 
(incorrectly?) reporting "pass."  I am including Doug Sanden since I 
think he was the originator of the file (attached). Other wise people 
might help too?

I don't see the problem given your explanation previously, Don.

Perhaps it's the initializeOnly's and inputOnly's that should be 
converted to inputOutput?

Still sort of puzzled.  I'm not aiming at wizardhood, just commenting on 
book titles ("Order of the Phoenix").

This time, the errors appear not scrunched up i hope.  There was a 
problem with paste before, some mysterious Thunderbird feature.

I will proceed by changing accessType on the fields.

Thanks,

John

7. Performing X3D Schematron check...
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector1'> <fieldValue 
name='startnode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[1]/fieldValue[1], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector1'> <fieldValue 
name='endnode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no corresponding 
field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[1]/fieldValue[2], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector1'> <fieldValue 
name='transnode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[1]/fieldValue[3], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector1'> <fieldValue 
name='rotscalenode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[1]/fieldValue[4], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector1'> <fieldValue 
name='set_startpoint' value='0 0 0'/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[1]/fieldValue[5], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector1'> <fieldValue 
name='set_endpoint' value='0 0 0'/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[1]/fieldValue[6], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector2'> <fieldValue 
name='startnode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[2]/fieldValue[1], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector2'> <fieldValue 
name='endnode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no corresponding 
field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[2]/fieldValue[2], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector2'> <fieldValue 
name='transnode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[2]/fieldValue[3], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector2'> <fieldValue 
name='rotscalenode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[2]/fieldValue[4], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector2'> <fieldValue 
name='set_startpoint' value='0 0 0'/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[2]/fieldValue[5], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector2'> <fieldValue 
name='set_endpoint' value='0 0 0'/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[2]/fieldValue[6], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector3'> <fieldValue 
name='startnode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[3]/fieldValue[1], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector3'> <fieldValue 
name='endnode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no corresponding 
field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[3]/fieldValue[2], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector3'> <fieldValue 
name='transnode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[3]/fieldValue[3], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector3'> <fieldValue 
name='rotscalenode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[3]/fieldValue[4], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector3'> <fieldValue 
name='set_startpoint' value='0 0 0'/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[3]/fieldValue[5], hint]
<ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector3'> <fieldValue 
name='set_endpoint' value='0 0 0'/> has matching ProtoDeclare but no 
corresponding field match for this fieldValue 
[/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[3]/fieldValue[6], hint]
X3D Schematron check: pass.
Good practice is to fix errors and warnings wherever possible, and 
consider silencing harmless informational messages, so that important 
indicators remain noticeable.

On 2/6/21 11:58 AM, Don Brutzman wrote:
> step by step...
>
> On 2/5/2021 1:55 AM, John Carlson wrote:
>>
>> Thanks, Don.   I will look over the X3D file some more later.
>
> gosh i love diagnostics!  um, compared to the alternative of no 
> diagnostics...
>
>> Should the order of the fieldValues match the order of fields?
>
> not required
>
>> I’m beginning to sound like Harry Potter. Lol
>
> We haven't yet defined a policy for "Web3D Wizard" but am sure that 
> consensus is possible following much concerted effort, controversy, 
> sound and fury...
>
>> Thanks!
>>
>> John
>
> happy to help when i can, you are finding the gaps/seams and we're all 
> in this together. take care.  8)
>
>> On Fri, Feb 5, 2021 at 2:11 AM Don Brutzman <brutzman at nps.edu 
>> <mailto:brutzman at nps.edu>> wrote:
>>
>>     These Schematron alerts are readable if you split them up. Here 
>> is explanation for first.
>>
>>     On 2/4/2021 10:54 PM, John Carlson wrote:
>>      > ProtoInstance name='x3dconnector' DEF='connector1'> 
>> <fieldValue name='startnode' value=''/> has matching ProtoDeclare but 
>> no corresponding field match for this fieldValue
>>
>>     The above warning says that your ProtoInstance named 
>> "x3dconnector" has an initial field value named "startnode", but 
>> there is no corresponding field "startnode" defined in the governing 
>> ProtoDeclare named "x3dconnector".
>>
>>     No name found usually means that you have a flawed 
>> ProtoInstance.  Though the mismatch/misunderstanding might be in the 
>> ProtoDeclare or ExternProtoDeclare.  As author, you must ensure that 
>> all the names match.
>>
>>      > [/X3D/Scene/ProtoInstance[1]/fieldValue[1], hint]
>
> p.s. i changed role attribute of this diagnostic from "hint" to 
> "error" since it is an error.
>
>>     This provides the location of the node in your scene graph.  Thus 
>> go to the X3D node, then the scene node, then the first ProtoInstance 
>> [1] , then the first fieldValue [1].
>>
>>     These are super helpful.  If the flaw is in your original X3D 
>> model, then stylesheets and other tools simply won't work - GIGO.
>>
>>     Good luck!
>
> all the best, Don
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: x3dconnectorProto.x3d
Type: model/x3d+xml
Size: 8739 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://web3d.org/pipermail/x3d-public_web3d.org/attachments/20210206/04e148c8/attachment-0001.x3d>